A recent Custody X Change study found that 93 percent of divorcing parents tried an alternative dispute resolution method – often more than once. Slightly more than half of all respondents used mediation, making it the most popular ADR method. What can we infer about mediation in family law cases based on these statistics?
Cost may be a barrier to trying ADR methods.
Fewer low-income respondents used an ADR method than their middle- or high-income counterparts (82 percent compared to 97 percent). This division among income brackets points to the possibility that lower-income parents are less likely to try mediation because of the cost.
While many courts offer free mediation, parents may be unaware of the programs or may have already exhausted the usually-limited time allotted. The cost – whether actual or perceived – may dissuade parents with less disposable income from trying mediation.
Using an ADR method may result in a more positive co-parenting relationship.
We can also see a possible correlation between ADR methods and how well parents get along.
Forty-eight percent of middle to high-income parents claim to get along “very well” or “extremely well” with their former spouse, compared to 30 percent of low-income parents. Due to their greater participation in ADR, it’s possible that using ADR methods contributed to the positive relationships of higher-income respondents.
Overall, parents who used ADR were almost twice as likely to rate their relationship highly following the divorce. Parents who are on good terms tend to have healthy co-parenting relationships.
ADR may increase the chances of parents having joint custody
The study found that high-income parents are more likely to have joint custody than low-income parents. This could possibly tie to their greater participation in ADR methods – and their higher rate of hiring an attorney.
Out of 778 people that got joint physical custody, 421 (54%) used mediation and 36 (5%) used no ADR.
When both parents are fit and able to get along, joint custody is viewed by many experts as the best custody arrangement. Children who have two active parents in their lives tend to fare better than those who do not.
Having an attorney may increase the likelihood of a settlement.
While it is a common belief that attorneys ramp up contention between parents, the study found that 86 percent of cases where both parents have an attorney settle. This is a significant difference from the rate of settlement when neither parent has an attorney (71 percent) and when only one parent has an attorney (63 percent).
Attorneys are helpful not only in litigation but also in the mediation process. They can provide moral support to their clients, ensure their rights are protected and help them get the best outcome for themselves and their child.
Disputing Blog by Karl Bayer, Victoria VanBuren, and Holly HayesThe Pew Charitable Trusts (“Pew”) has reportedly issued a call for the establishment of a national body to standardize online dispute...By Beth Graham
After several attempts over many years, on 10 May 2022 the Nigerian Parliament passed a new Commercial Arbitration and Mediation Bill (H.B. 91). The Bill is currently awaiting signature of...By Hiro Aragaki