Why I Don’t Want to Know Your Bottom Line: Reason No. One

“Please don’t tell me your bottom line,” I say to attorneys who are new to my mediation practice.

It’s rare to be asked “why.”   Recently, however, an attorney told me that one of my ADR colleagues always commences mediations by expressly asking for her bottom line.

“It’s just like trial,” I said, “or taking depositions, both of which I teach for the National Institute of Trial Advocacy.

It drives the new lawyer students a little crazy to get conflicting advice from the seasoned litigators and trial lawyers who critique their work.  But really, it’s their first lesson in rubber-hitting-the-road legal practice.  At the end of the day, whatever works best for them is the correct way of doing it.”

That said, I went on to explain why I don’t want to know the parties’ bottom lines.

“Because it will influence me whether I think it will or not.”

As Diane Levin notes in her recent post think you’re neutral? Bias hard to detect in ourselves, because neutrality is the foundation of our practice, it behooves us to recognize our biases.

More importantly, it’s best for us to remember that we won’t be able to identify those biases that are most deeply ingrained in us.  

Here are two of Diane’s links to greater coverage of this topic:

From The Situationist: “I’m Objective, You’re Biased“, which looks at “bias blind spots”–the extent to which many of us readily spot bias in others while remaining blind to our own.

And from ScientificAmerican.com,”Not-so-deliberate: The decisive power of what you don’t know you know“, which looks at the ways in which “even seemingly rational, straightforward, conscious decisions about arbitrary matters can easily be biased by inputs coming in below our radar of awareness.”


Victoria Pynchon

Attorney-mediator Victoria Pynchon is a panelist with ADR Services, Inc. Ms. Pynchon was awarded her LL.M Degree in Dispute Resolution from the Straus Institute in May of 2006, after 25 years of complex commercial litigation practice, with sub-specialties in intellectual property, securities fraud, antitrust, insurance coverage, consumer class actions and all… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Is Interest-Based Mediation Derived From A Misunderstanding?

From Arnold W. Zeman's blog>Regular readers of this blog know that I practise mediation using the transformative model. (For more information, please see the tag, transformative mediation.) The most prominent...

By Arnold W. Zeman

Federal Circuit Ducks Question of Federal Mediation Privilege

Diapers have been the subject of numerous patents and patent infringement lawsuits. In this case, K-C is suing its competitor, First Quality, for infringing more than a dozen diaper related...

By Dennis Crouch

The Five Most Effective Ways To Break Negotiation Impasse: Part III

In that most famous of sales movies,David Mamet's Glengarry Glen Ross, the under-appreciated Alec Baldwin gave his sorry group of cold-callers the prime directive of sales:  Always Be Closing.  You...

By Victoria Pynchon

Find a Mediator