Find Mediators Near You:

What We Can Learn From Law Students

From the blog of Nancy Hudgins

The American Bar Association, Law Student Division, hosts a variety of negotiation tournaments for law students. I spent a Saturday afternoon recently as a judge of an early round of the in-school competition at UC-Hastings College of Law.

The students are being taught that the outcome of a negotiation is successful when the settlement:

• Is better than the best alternative to a negotiated agreement (with this party)
• Satisfies the interests of:
the client – very well
the other side – acceptably (enough for them to agree and follow through)
third parties – tolerably (so they won’t disrupt the agreement)
• Adopts a solution that is the best of all available options
• Is legitimate – no one feels “taken”
• Involves commitments that are clear, realistic, and operational
• Involves communication that is efficient and well-understood, and
• Results in an enhanced working relationship, so the parties and/or their attorneys can deal with future differences more easily.

Here’s the behavior I saw from the law student participants:

They talked face-to-face.
They were respectful.
They tried to surface the other side’s underlying issues.
They were curious and tried to understand the other side’s views.
They advocated successfully without resorting to pressure tactics or bullying.
They carried on a civil conversation about the issues in the lawsuit.

And guess what? They think this is the norm! If your last mediation was not conducted in this manner, think about adopting some of the goals the ABA is trying to teach: an enhanced buy-in by the parties to the settlement agreement and an enhanced relationship between clients and counsel based on good communication skills.


Nancy Hudgins

Nancy Hudgins, a San Francisco mediator and lawyer, began specializing in civil litigation in the 1970's. She has represented both plaintiffs and defendants, chiefly in personal injury, medical malpractice, elder abuse and product liability lawsuits, but also in a wide variety of complex litigation, including civil rights, fraud and class… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


To Caucus Or Not To Caucus – That Is The Question

I have served clients in mediation in many roles -- as mediator, as reviewing attorney, as client’s attorney in the background, and as client’s advocating attorney at mediation sessions. I...

By Laurie Israel

Making The Most Of LinkedIn In 2009

Making the most of LinkedIn in 2009 LinkedIn is one of the premier online networking sites for business professionals worldwide. Chances are you’re already on LinkedIn and have begun to...

By Tammy Lenski

Explaining Mediation to Non-Mediators: How Hard Can it Be?

CMP Resolution Blog by John Crawley, Lesley Allport and Katherine Graham. I’m often surprised at how mediators and the mediation world talks about mediation to the people they want to...

By Katherine Graham