What Difference Does A Robe Make? Comparing Mediators With And Without Prior Judicial Experience

An intriguing article (abstract only) in July’s Negotiation Journal (Jul 2009. Vol. 25) by Stephen Goldberg, Margaret Shaw, Jeanne Brett reporting the results of two studies;

“… a glance at the rosters of some of the major mediation providers shows that between 40 percent and 60 percent of their mediators are former judges. This influx of former judges into the mediation ranks raises several questions that we address in this article:

1. Are former judges achieving success as mediators of commercial and employment disputes and, if so, why?
2. What are the characteristics and skills of those former judges who have succeeded as mediators?
3. Do former judges succeed as mediators for the same reasons as mediators who have not been judges?
4. What are the reasons why some former judges have not succeeded as mediators?

The first study, based on the responses of attorneys to questions about the reasons for the success of mediators with and without prior judicial experience, shows that the capacity of the mediator to gain the confidence of the disputants was most important for mediators with and without prior judicial experience.

Although certain process skills were viewed as important to the success of both former judges and nonjudges, in general, process skills were significantly more important for nonjudges than for former judges. The capacity to provide useful case evaluations, on the other hand, was significantly more important for former judges than for nonjudges.

The second study, based upon attorney responses to questions about unsatisfactory mediators, reinforced the conclusions of the first study regarding the importance of confidence-building attributes.

For both judges and nonjudges, the mediator’s inability to gain the confidence of the parties was a major reason for his or her lack of success.”

                        author

Geoff Sharp

Geoff Sharp is a Commercial Mediator from Wellington, New Zealand. Geoff works in the Asia Pacific region, including New Zealand, Malaysia, Thailand and Pacific Islands. He is a mediator resolving business problems. He is a fellow of the International Academy of Mediators and mediates complex and hotly debated litigation covering… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Recent Study Shows Bad Workplace Apples Do Indeed Spoil the Barrel

According to the results of a study reported in the journal Research in Organizational Behavior, bad apples really do spoil it for their co-workers. This will come as no surprise...

By Diane J. Levin
Category

Peter Salem: Defining Mediation for Marketing – Video

Peter Salem discusses why so many in the field want to define mediation. He sees it as a platform from which to market a profession. There needs to be a...

By Peter Salem
Category

Mediate.com Podcast Episode 16: Moving from Combative to Collaborative with Teresa Harlow

The Mediate.com Podcast, hosted by mediator Veronica Cravener, covers everything in the world of mediation. In Episode 16, Teresa Harlow--author, speaker, and collaboration coach--discusses the importance of mindset when moving from "combative to...

By Teresa Harlow, Veronica Cravener

Find a Mediator

X
X
X