Using Mediation to Resolve Tax Disputes

  • Kluwer Mediation Blog

    Her Majesty’s Revenue & Customs (HMRC), a department of the UK Government responsible for the collection of taxes, published the results of its pilot ADR project evaluation. It has been testing a new way of resolving tax disputes, with the SMEs and individual taxpayers, since 2011.

    The way the scheme works is that an official from HMRC, who has not been involved in the case already in any way and who has been specially trained to act as a mediator, works with the parties to the dispute to try to broker an agreement. Expected to remain neutral, the mediator sits down with a tax official familiar with the case and the taxpayer themselves, holding discussions to move towards a final agreement. In some circumstances, the two parties can agree to jointly pay for a professional mediator from outside HMRC.

    The evaluation shows that the project has been a success. If appropriately used, mediation results in significant time and cost efficiencies for both taxpayers and the tax authority. Two-thirds of applicants to the scheme left with either a partial or full resolution to their claim, with the majority (58%) seeing their cases completely resolved.

    HMRC announced that the system is to be rolled out as one of its standard services. It will be interesting to see how the program develops in the UK, and whether other countries decide to follow.


    Rafal Morek

    Dr. Rafal Morek is an associate in the firm’s Warsaw office. He has extensive experience representing clients in commercial disputes before both state courts and arbitral tribunals. He also has vast experience in representing clients in the financial sector, in respect of contracts and real properties.  Prior to joining K&L… MORE >

  • Featured Mediators

    View all

    Read these next


    Resolving Environmental Disputes With Environmental Team Mediation: A New Model

    I. THE STANDARD TRIAL MODEL We peek in at the closing arguments in the case of NewPuke Co. v. MegaDeth Corp., an environmental lawsuit brought by the current owner of...

    By Michael Young

    Venting Anger: A Good Habit to Break

    From the Mediator Tech blog of Tammy Lenski.Go ahead, said the encounter group facilitator, hit each other! Let it out! Let the other know how angry you are and stop...

    By Tammy Lenski

    Never Cut What You Can Untie

    Cinergy Coaching by Cinnie Noble Recently on the Conflict Coaching Guild on LinkedIn I asked members if they would share idioms, phrases, metaphors and other expressions on conflict that they...

    By Cinnie Noble

    Find a Mediator