The International Challenge

JAMS ADR Blog by Chris Poole

As ADR providers have begun expanding worldwide, a global shift towards ADR has gained momentum. Change at this pace generates interesting challenges and worthwhile debate as new entrants bring fresh ideas and new methodologies to the market.


Most of the 27 EU Member States implemented the European Union Directive legislation in 2011, which provided a consistent approach to confidentiality and the recognition and enforcement of mediation agreements. States, for various reasons, adopted the Directive differently. Italy took the most radical approach, with the result that mediation is now a mandatory precursor to the use of the courts for a wide range of civil disputes.

The Italian model raises taxing questions for mediation globally, being born of a broken civil justice system rather than the more familiar need to save time and legal costs. By 2011, the civil courts in Italy had a backlog of 5.4 million cases and an average processing time of eight years. Mediation was touted as the best available solution to these problems. By contrast, ADR in the United States has risen in prominence precisely because it is complimentary to the courts: a credible threat of judicial determination is the elephant in many of mediation rooms.

Given such different starting points, different mediation styles inevitably follow, which raises some practical challenges in managing cross-border and cross-continental disputes.

Fortunately mediation can respond and including a mediation clause in business contracts is becoming a more attractive and popular option. Among mediation’s advantages are total procedural flexibility and the ability to evolve as the market requires. At a practical level therefore, in cross-continental matters mediators are encouraged to develop a “mid-Atlantic” style. At its most basic, this involves throwing away the rule book, and adapting an approach to suit either side. It means being tough enough on the legal merits to engage U.S. clients, but leaving scope for parties to determine the outcome themselves.

As business becomes more “glocal” and jurisdictions become blurred, charting out ahead of time what is important to you or client can prevent a lot of wasted time and money. Additionally, mediation has proven effective at not only resolving all types of conflicts, but more importantly, leaving the business relationship intact so future business can still occur. Therefore, inserting a mediation clause, indicating both the name of the mediation service provider and the city where the procedure will take place, can aid in the process of an effective and efficient resolution.

With more than 20 languages and various legal traditions, the EU can still look like a daunting place to resolve business disputes efficiently and cost-effectively. With some creative thinking and appropriate infrastructure, most challenges can be overcome. Traditional barriers of language and culture have been successfully managed using co-mediation; process and style are on-going and fascinating challenges, but mediation can change to meet market demands.

Cross-border and cross-continental mediation is still new and evolving. How experiments like those in Italy impact the theory and practice of mediation over the next decade make these exciting times for global ADR.



Matthew Rushton

Matthew Rushton began a career as a legal journalist in 1997 writing for The Legal 500 in the UK, continental Europe, and Asia Pacific regions. He subsequently wrote for a wide range of legal periodicals in the UK and US, including Legal Business magazine where he was a senior reporter and litigation editor (2000-2003). As… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


CPR International Conference Highlights: ‘Effects on Cross-Border Disputes After the Singapore Convention’

CPR Speaks BlogAccording to the Singapore Convention on Mediation’s website, the Convention is a “multilateral treaty which offers a uniform and efficient framework for the enforcement and invocation of international agreements...

By Bryanna Rainwater

A Real Case of Prisoner’s Dilemma

PGP Mediation Blog by Phyllis G. PollackOne of the first things I Iearned about in game theory was the prisoner’s dilemma. As explained in Wikipedia, this theory was developed in...

By Phyllis Pollack

International Mediation Developments – January 2014

This is another in a series of updates on international mediation developments by News Editor, Keith Seat.The E.U.’s Office for Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM) offers mediation for...

By Keith Seat

Find a Mediator