Settling Personal Injury Cases

From Michael P. Carbone’s Mediation

Strategies Blog

In my last post I discussed the need for thorough preparation before going to mediation. In particular, I noted the need to prepare the opposition, which may have surprised some readers. Why, you might ask, should I prepare the opposition as well as myself? Why can’t they prepare their own case?

Sounds fair alright, but if you are the plaintiff you need to give the insurance carrier every reason that you can think of to put the highest possible value on your claim. Don’t count on them to find those reasons for themselves; they might be too busy thinking of reasons to do just the opposite.

Some injured parties and their counsel will come to a mediation with a “hide the ball” attitude. Rather than lay out all of their evidence, they prefer to keep their best points hidden so that they can surprise the other side at trial. This strategy is almost always wrong.

First, the vast majority of cases are settled, so there will not be a trial. Even more importantly though, insurance carriers and their counsel will do their internal evaluation of your case before the mediation and make a determination of what they are willing to pay in order to settle. You want them to be looking at your strong points when they arrive at that number.

None of us like surprises, except on our birthdays or other festive occasions. If you conceal your good evidence and then decide to reveal it later in order to support a higher settlement demand, you will only irritate the other side.

The mediation is the most important event in your case.  The day of the mediation is the day when it should be resolved.  Prepare thoroughly, lay all your cards on the table, and give the defense everything that they will need.  Do it well before the mediation so that they will have time to take all of the facts into account.


Michael P. Carbone

MICHAEL P. CARBONE is a senior mediator who has also served as an arbitrator and court-appointed referee. His dispute resolution practice has been built over a period of more than 25 years and covers a wide range of fields.   His exceptional combination of transactional and litigation experience enables him to handle complex litigation… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Accessing Justice

A recent article n the ABA Journal on movements to license legal technicians to perform limited legal services cited a Bar Foundation study showing that most people encountering what the...

By Joe Markowitz

Listening to Transcend Conflict

What will it take to transform our inner struggles and tumultuous encounters into healing relationships? We all know that listening is vital for resolving conflicts. What more then can be...

By Deborah Isenhour, Marilyn Shannon

Navigating the Listening in Mediation

“When there is a patient listener  the speaker starts listening to the speaker within the speaker”.  Decision making process and the act of  decision taking are two aspects that  govern...

By Sarathi Susheela

Find a Mediator