PGP Mediation Blog by Phyllis G. Pollack

Once again, The Economist reported on another quirky study. In an article entitled “Tall dark and stable” in the psychology section of its July 14, 2012 edition, the author discusses how “wobbly furniture leads to a desire for emotional stability.”

Evidently, previous studies have shown that if one is given an icy drink at a party, that person will perceive that she is getting the cold shoulder from the other party goers. Similarly, giving a person a warm drink leads her to perceive a sense of warmth. Of greater interest, especially in this election year, are studies showing that if potential voters are sitting in chairs leaning slightly to the left, they, somehow, become more amenable to “liberal” or left leaning viewpoints!

The most recent study, which is the topic of this article, has to do with the effect of furniture on a person’s perceptions. David Kille, Amanda Forest and Joanne Wood at the University of Waterloo in Canada, had one-half of their volunteers sit in a slightly wobbly chair next to a slightly wobbly table while performing some task. The other one-half of the volunteers sat in non-wobbly chairs next to stable tables.

Those sitting in the wobbly chairs were then asked to judge the stability of the relationships of several celebrities, including President and Mrs. Obama, David and Victoria Beckham, Jay-Z and Beyonce and Johnny Depp and Vanessa Paradis. Using a scale of one to seven, the volunteers rated how likely the couple would break up within the next five years, in which “1” meant “extremely unlikely to dissolve“.

The researchers found that tinkering with the stability of the furniture effected the volunteer’s perception of stability:

“…[F]eelings of physical instability leads to perceptions of social instability. Participants who sat in wobbly chairs at wobbly tables gave the celebrity couples an average stability score of 3.2 while those whose furniture did not wobble gave them a 2.5.”

Based on additional tasks given to those in the wobbly chairs, the researchers also found that these individuals “…valued stability in their own relationships more highly.”

This study presents some interesting thoughts in terms of negotiation and mediation. The most obvious is if wobbly furniture is used, the person sitting in it may well perceive her side of the dispute to be less secure than it really is, or, to the contrary, that the other party’s side of the dispute to be less secure than it really is and that her own side is much more stable. Or, it will cause the person to value stability more and so agree to a settlement providing it.

In a more general sense, this study reinforces the notion that our perception of reality and true “reality” are not the same. What we “perceive” to be true, often times, is not! Our brain can, indeed, play tricks on us, and we are even aware of it.

….. Just something to think about!


Phyllis Pollack

Phyllis Pollack with PGP Mediation uses a facilitative, interest-based approach. Her preferred mediation style is facilitative in the belief that the best and most durable resolutions are those achieved by the parties themselves. The parties generally know the business issues and priorities, personalities and obstacles to a successful resolution as… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


A Strong Foundation in Canadian Collaborative, Consensus Processes

Originally posted by the ADR Institute of Alberta. Why is collaboration so important in today’s world?  The main reason is that the problems we have to solve today are more...

By Robyn Jacobsen

Dispute System Design for Facebook

Indisputably The New York Times published an interesting article worth reading, which riffs on Mark Zuckerberg’s statement that Facebook would develop an independent body to make decisions about acceptability of...

By John Lande

The Mindful Mediator

After a very long three days working with His Holiness the Dalai Lama here in New York City, it was great to see the term 'mindfulness' popping up in the...

By Jeff Thompson

Find a Mediator