Peace In; Peace Out

Fairly Legal Blog by Clare Fowler

I just watched the Season Premier of Fairly Legal and was caught off-guard by the demeanor of Kate, the mediator and main character. She was pushy, she was adversarial, and she was condescending.

Mind you, she also got her clients a great deal.

But is it our job as mediators to win-win at all costs? Or to win-win, if that is the best thing for everyone, and if it helps them to be better in the long run.

There were multiple scenarios in the season premier where Kate fought hard for the money for her clients. But her aggressive personality left so many people feeling windswept that they were not satisfied with the outcome. Yes, on paper, both clients won. One side got an apology; the other side got a fair settlement. But they did not reach the settlement on their own. So neither side was able to feel the satisfaction of arriving at a fair settlement. Emotionally they were pushed to a satisfaction instead of having time to realize what it was they really wanted.

As mediators I prefer to bring peace to people from a place of peace. If I am anxious, tense, trying to prove something, or slaying my own dragons, I am not best serving my client. When these emotions arise, I feel it is best to call it a day, give everyone a chance to think, and plan on speaking again the following day. The agreement will look the same, but the clients will be at peace. Making it a win, win, and a deep contented sigh.

                        author

Clare Fowler

Clare Fowler is Executive Vice-President and Managing Editor at Mediate.com.  Clare received her Master's of Dispute Resolution from the Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution at the Pepperdine University School of Law and her Doctorate in Organizational Leadership, focused on reducing workplace conflicts, from Pepperdine University School of Education. Clare also coordinated… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Is Agreement the Gold Standard for Mediation Success?

Perhaps because mediated agreements, especially written ones, are tangible and easily quantified, they have long served as a popular measure of mediation success and mediator competence.  Indeed, a number of...

By Alan E. Gross
Category

Relooking at Sacred Cows . . .

Kluwer Mediation Blog[Author's Note: I am grateful to Ms. Melissa Teo whose journal ruminations led me to the random thoughts that follow] I teach mediation skills at the National University...

By Joel Lee
Category

Takeaways from a Child Protection Mediator Training

Just Court ADR by Susan M. Yates, Jennifer Shack, Heather Scheiwe Kulp, and Jessica Glowinski.On January 20-21, RSI put on an advanced two-day training for the mediators in our new...

By Eric Slepak

Find a Mediator

X
X
X