On Settling Employment Cases

This article was reprinted by the Michael Carbone listserv.

All too frequently the employment relationship leads to disputes that result in litigation. Mediators see a wide variety of claims, such as wrongful termination, harassment, discrimination, and violation of wage and hour rules.

When preparing to mediate an employment case we must appreciate the need of both sides to be heard. The employee feels that he or she has been wronged, but often the employer will feel the same way simply because a lawsuit has been filed.

Settlements can be negotiated, but before talking about terms we need to listen to what the parties are saying. Joint sessions can be useful, but they can also be counterproductive. Too many joint sessions are confrontational rather than conciliatory.

Customization of the process is the key to success and the participants should consider taking the following steps.

Delay the joint session. The parties should first talk privately with the mediator and have a chance to “settle down.” Many parties are tense or nervous when they arrive at the mediation. Or they may be anxious to confront the other side with accusations.

Choose carefully the persons who will participate. The “wrongdoer” may be so defensive as to drive the two sides further apart. It is better to have a different employer representative present, especially the person who has the actual authority to settle.

Provide a meaningful opportunity for an apology. If an apology is to be made it must be given face-to-face. I have seen it done in a joint session and at other times it has been done privately. The claimant might meet with the supervisor or with someone in a higher position of authority. Remember that an apology is not necessarily an admission of liability and that mediation confidentiality provides a safe environment.


Michael P. Carbone

MICHAEL P. CARBONE is a senior mediator who has also served as an arbitrator and court-appointed referee. His dispute resolution practice has been built over a period of more than 25 years and covers a wide range of fields.   His exceptional combination of transactional and litigation experience enables him to handle complex litigation… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Fallacious Argument Of The Month

There’s nothing like a good argument, as any fan of Monty Python knows. Having a good argument, however, demands diligence, attention to detail, self-awareness, and practice; it’s all too easy...

By Diane J. Levin

Sanctions for Baseless Motion to Vacate Arbitration Award

Business Conflict Blog by Peter Phillips The District Court for the Southern District of New York has awarded attorney’s fees to a party who incurred those expenses responding to a...

By F. Peter Phillips

Do You Fall Prey to the Einstellung Effect in Problem Solving?

Tammy Lenski's Conflict Zen BlogThe Einstellung effect is a type of cognitive trap that prevents us from seeing better solutions to problems we want to solve and conflicts we want...

By Tammy Lenski

Find a Mediator