Mediator’s Proposal: Take It Or Leave It

Both sides seem to be progressing to resolution, but have hit a wall.  Is it time for the mediator to make a proposal for settlement?  If so, should the mediator use the value that the case is worth (which one side or the other likely won’t accept), or the value that the mediator thinks will settle the case?

The typical “mediator’s proposal” is given to both sides as a take-it-or-leave-it proposition to resolve the case.  Each party can confidentially accept or reject the proposal without compromising their negotiating position.  The problem is that the mediator knows who accepted, and who didn’t, and it usually means the exit of the mediator from the matter.  In other words, the mediator only gets one bite at the apple.

The technique can have dramatic results.  A reluctant plaintiff will make a large jump if the money is really “on the table.”  Defendants will come up with money they otherwise deny having, if it means that the case is really over.  It also eliminates reactive devaluation.

Generally, the mediator should choose a number that both sides could agree to, rather than a number that the mediator thinks they should agree to.  If the parties think that the mediator might make an evaluative proposal, they will approach the mediation like a mini arbitration right from the start.

The mediator should not discuss a proposal until the parties ask for it, or at least until the mediation seems to be over.  It is best to set a cut-off time for a simple “yes” or “no” response, allow no negotiating with the mediator about the proposal, and unless there is a deal, don’t end the time period early.  Someone could change their mind at the eleventh hour.

                        author

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Negotiation 101: What Parties Should Know About Negotiations at the Mediation Table

INTRODUCTION For many, especially those new to the process of settling legal disputes, negotiations across the mediation table are like nothing the parties have ever experienced before. The purpose of...

By Sheldon Stark
Category

Saadia Touval, 76, Expert on Mediation Issues

From the Washington Post,Friday, April 25, 2008 Saadia Touval, 76, a political scientist who made an influential argument that biased mediators in international disputes were often the most effective, died...

By
Category

Usurpation Of Freewill In The Age Of Discretion

Life is more manageable through aging because conflict resolution is an ability that can be perfected through practice. Time teaches what reason cannot is illustrated in a popular expression: The...

By Luis Miguel Diaz

Find a Mediator

X
X
X