Martha Stewart Living Ordered to Mediate Dispute With Macy’s and J.C. Penney

Disputing Blog by Karl Bayer, Victoria VanBuren, Beth Graham, and Holly Hayes

Mediation is in the news again. Last week, a New York judge ordered a dispute between Macy’s, Inc., J.C. Penney Co., and Martha Stewart Living to mediation. The lawsuit itself reportedly arose after New York-based Martha Stewart Living signed a contract with Plano-based J.C. Penney to open a Martha Stewart mini shop in many of the retailer’s stores. In a separate case filed three months later, Cincinnati-based Macy’s sued J.C. Penney for interfering with the company’s contract with Martha Stewart Living. The two cases were later consolidated for a bench trial in New York State Supreme Court (Manhattan).

During the third week of trial, a dispute purportedly arose over whether Macy’s has the exclusive right to sell certain Martha Stewart Living items. Macy’s has reportedly sold Martha Stewart branded items in its stores since 2007. In December 2011, J.C. Penney acquired a 17 percent stake in the home merchandise brand. As a result of the disagreement and failing communication between the parties, Judge Jeffrey Oing ordered the three companies to engage in mediation before April 8th. J.C. Penney has also agreed to refrain from selling Martha Stewart Living merchandise until that date.

Stay tuned to Disputing for future updates about this case.


Beth Graham

Beth Graham received a J.D. from the University of Nebraska College of Law in 2004 and a M.A. in Information Science and Learning Technologies from the University of Missouri in 2006. She also holds a B.S. in Public Administration from the University of Nebraska-Omaha. She is licensed to practice law… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


The Business Owner’s Dilemma: Arbitration Or Mediation

This article was published in the February 2009 issue of Enterprise, an on-line publication of the Greater Kalamazoo Chamber of Commerce.Last week the owner of a small business called me...

By Jeff Murphy

Saving Homes, Building Understanding

Just Court ADR by Susan M. Yates, Jennifer Shack, Heather Scheiwe Kulp, and Jessica Glowinski.Resolution Systems Institute is proud to share its latest publication, Saving Homes, Building Understanding: An Evaluation of the...

By Eric Slepak

Effective Alternatives Analysis In Mediation: “BATNA/WATNA” Analysis Demystified

BATNA: Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement WATNA: Worst Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement Popular Attribution to Fisher & Ury, Getting to Yes. Introduction: In most settlement negotiations, parties are...

By Jessica Notini

Find a Mediator