Got Disputes? Asian/Western Insights on Commercial Dispute Resolution

With rapid growth in commercial dealings between Asian nations and an ever-expanding number of partners, the likelihood of disputes grows along with opportunities for greater understanding and early resolution.

Often, many assume that the approach to resolution in the Asia Pacific is monolithic.  Rather, recent empirical research published in Resolving Disputes in the Asia Pacific: International Arbitration and Mediation in East Asia and the West, shows that a great deal of variation exists within the region.  For example, in some countries such as Japan, conciliation attempts are often integrated within arbitral proceedings, while in Hong Kong, formalized multi-tier dispute resolution mechanisms are often used particularly in the area of construction disputes. 

Another common assumption is that there is a wide chasm between the way disputes are resolved in the so-called ‘West’ and ‘East Asia’.  In fact, in a number of areas, there is a great deal of harmonization in practice. Building on the influence of Model Laws and Rules such as those developed by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, increasing harmonization exists with respect to arbitral pre-hearing directives, party statement of claims and defenses, oral hearings, use of experts, taking of evidence, and issuing of awards.

At the same time, the practice of international arbitration is enriched by regional diversity. This is demonstrated, for example, by a greater openness to exploring settlement options and a greater degree of support for arbitrator-initiated settlement discussions among practitioners working in East Asia.

Drawing on interviews and surveys with over 115 arbitrators, judges, lawyers and members of the rapidly expanding arbitration community in China, Hong Kong, Korea, Japan, Singapore, and Malaysia as well as North America and Europe, the book Resolving Disputes in the Asia Pacific Region: International Arbitration and Mediation in East Asia and the West (Routledge), aims to contribute to the wider discussion on effective mechanisms of resolving commercial disputes.  The book will be of interest to practitioners, students and scholars of international arbitration and dispute resolution, comparative and Asian law, as well as anyone dealing with potential conflict in international business relationships in East Asia.

                        author

Shahla Ali

Dr. Shahla Ali, is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Law at the University of Hong Kong.  Her teaching and research focus on arbitration and dispute resolution, international commercial transactions and law and development in East Asia.  Prior to joining the faculty of law, she worked at the international… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Focusing on Alternative Dispute Resolution: A Conversation With Two JAMS Neutrals

JAMS ADR Blog by Chris PooleHon. Betty Weinberg Ellerin (Ret.) and Hon. Sherry Klein Heitler (Ret.) served on the bench in New York State for more than 25 years before...

By Betty Weinberg Elerin, Sherry Klein Heitler
Category

The Subtleties of Memory

PGP Mediation Blog by Phyllis G. PollackAll disputes are premised on what occurred in the past with the view of resolving them by looking forward. We are often told not...

By Phyllis Pollack
Category

Getting Hitched? 6 Tips for Pre-Marriage Relationships

From Marriage.comYou’re getting married soon and you’re excited about it.   But wait! What are the things you must talk about and change before tying the knot so that you both...

By Adriane Beth

Find a Mediator

X
X
X