Fifth Circuit Overturns Class Action Arbitration Decision

Health Care Neutral ADR Blog by Richard Webb

In Reed v. Florida Metropolitan University, Inc., No. 11-50509 (5th Cir. May 18, 2012), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that an arbitrator exceeded his powers in finding the parties' agreement authorized class arbitration (hat tip to Victoria VanBuren at Disputing). The case is remarkably similar to Sutter v. Oxford Health Plans, in which the Third Circuit reached the opposite conclusion, as discussed here previously.

In Reed, the court found no express agreement to engage in class action arbitration, and refused to accept the arbitrator's interpretation of the parties' contract, which inferred class action intent from language referring to "any dispute." The court further rejected any argument that the absence of language prohibiting class action arbitration can be used to infer class action intent. In both regards, the Fifth Circuit based its opinion squarely on the Supreme Court's decision in Stolt-Nielsen.

You can't explain the different outcomes in Reed and Sutter by distinguishing them on the facts. The two courts clearly wanted to adopt very different views of Stolt-Nielsen. Other Circuits have addressed the issue as well. See, e.g., Jock v. Sterling Jewelers, 646 F.3d. 113 (2nd Cir. 2011). Drafters of arbitration clauses and those choosing their arbitration venue should act accordingly.

                        author

Richard J. Webb

In addition to providing alternative dispute resolution services, Richard J .Webb practices law as Richard J. Webb, LLC. He has been engaged in the private practice of law in New Jersey since 1978, focusing on the healthcare industry for the last 27 years. Before starting his own firm he was… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

The Energy of Conflict: An Emerging Paradigm

How do you see conflict? For most of us, we experience conflict as a heavy burden and an energy drain. In fact, as mediators, we often see the weight of...

By Deborah Isenhour, Marilyn Shannon
Category

Elder Mediation

Eldercare mediation is a growing field that will increase in prominence as the number of elders increases. As parents age, conflicts can erupt between parents and their children over living...

By Georgia Daniels
Category

Collaborative Problem Solving: An Effective Approach For Managing Conflict In The Workplace

The workplace is a complex interpersonal environment where conflict inevitably occurs. When handled poorly, conflict undermines relationships, team performance, and morale. It keeps managers and staff alike up at night,...

By Seth Bernstein, Stuart Ablon

Find a Mediator

X
X
X