Fault Lines/Property Lines in Conflict

Blog by
Lorraine Segal

Fault lines—as a Californian I’m familiar with fault lines, the locations where tectonic plates meet and can shift, creating earthquakes. I live right on one of the smaller ones, the Steven’s Creek fault line in Santa Rosa CA.

But it occurred to me that fault lines could refer to how we assign blame in a conflict. We generally draw the line to show that most of the fault is on their side of the line, and almost none on our side. And the other person may do the same.

But unlike an earthquake where we have almost no control over the noise, the shaking, the energy, in a conflict we can shift or redefine fault lines. Instead of hollering at each other from opposite sides, we can build a bridge between their perspective and our own.

Part of this is shifting from blame to contributiona concept I originally learned about in the classic book, Difficult Conversations, how to discuss what matters most. One of their suggestions for navigating conflict more skillfully, is to look at your own part. I fervently believe that in any conflict, both participants have a share in the problem and misunderstanding.

Property Lines

Another way of looking at our contribution to a problem is to think of it in terms of property lines. If you own a home or building, property lines are where one piece of real estate stops and another begins. There is a whole specialization in the mediation field about real estate, and some disputes are literally about property lines.

But this concept is useful in many other kinds of conflicts when we ask, “What’s my conflict “property” and what’s theirs?” My opinions, judgements, and the story I tell about what happened are my property. And their assumptions, opinions etc. are theirs, not mine.

Pause and assess fault lines and property lines

Instead of immediately reacting, when we can pause, and thoughtfully assess fault lines and property lines in a conflict we are in, we can begin to listen better and understand that multiple perspectives are possible. Simply asking yourself, “What’s my part, my fault (line), my property (line)?”, can help you expand your perspective instead of staying stuck in a narrow judgment. This by itself won’t necessarily be enough to resolve the conflict to both people’s satisfaction, but it is a helpful start to a calmer, more productive conversation.


Lorraine Segal

Lorraine Segal, M.A. is a Conflict Management and Communication Consultant, Coach, and Trainer. Through her own business, Conflict Remedy, Ms. Segal works with corporations and non-profits as well as governmental entities and individuals to promote harmonious and productive workplaces.  She is a consultant and trainer for County of Sonoma. And, at Sonoma… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Princess Inaara Speaks in Support of Mediation (video)

"Mediation is respectful cooperation in conflict and an intelligent and human way of thinking>" In this video, Princess Inaara of Jordan (Her Highness the Begum Aga Khan) speaks eloquently in...

By Princess Inaara

Joe Folger: Conflict in the Field – Video

The most widely used mediation model places an emphasis on helping people find common ground. His model is different. Transformative mediation is about supporting people in their differences if that...

By Joseph P. Folger

I Sound Like A Broken Record: Come Prepared

From the Blog of Phyllis G. Pollack. If I had to list one thing that is a must for mediation, it would be “preparation.” I raise this again for the...

By Phyllis Pollack

Find a Mediator