Dividing the Marital Home

Joy Rosenthal’s Mediation Blog

One of the things that needs to be decided in a divorce is how you’re going to divide up what you own together, and one of the biggest assets that couples usually own is their home. There are several choices as to what happens to the house (or condo or co-op):

  • You can sell the house and divide the proceeds.
  • You can continue to own the house together, even if one person stays there.
  • You can buy out your spouse’s portion.
  • Your spouse can buy out your portion.

How do you decide who gets what?

Let’s say you sell the house to a third person, so you know the sale price. First, subtract the amount that’s owed on the mortgage, any transfer or capital gains taxes, and closing costs.

Then subtract the contributions each spouse might have made from separate property for the down payment.

The remaining part is your joint equity in the house. You decide how you will split it (usually 50/50, but not always).

Here is an example: Let’s say that Bonnie and Clyde own a house together that they sell for $500,000. They have a mortgage for $160,000, and the closing costs, taxes, etc. will be $40,000.  Bonnie contributed $50,000 and Clyde contributed $100,000 when they purchased it.

Here is the math:

Equity = $500,000

Minus mortgage and closing costs ($200,000) = $300,000

Minus $50,000 to Bonnie, and $100,000 to Clyde = $150,000

Equity divided by 2 = $75,000 each

So Bonnie ends up with $125,000 (75,000 + 50,000) and

Clyde ends up with $175,000 (75,000 + 100,000)

Now, what if you are NOT selling to a third party, but one person wanted to buy out the other’s share? In the above example, Bonnie would have to come up with $175,000 to purchase Clyde’s share, or Clyde would have to come up with $125,000 to purchase Bonnie’s share.

Of course, real life often gives us a more complicated scenario. And notice that there are some things that are NOT included in the above example — such as money one partner laid out for household expenses other than the mortgage, or for non-monetary contributions to the home that increased its value. In that case, the division above may seem one-sided.

This is an excellent reason to choose mediation or collaborative law: to hand craft an agreement for your unique situation and to create something that is fair (and workable) for your family!


Joy Rosenthal

Joy S. Rosenthal, Esq. is a compassionate mediator, a skilled negotiator and an intelligent litigator with extensive background in the private and public sectors. Joy served as a Staff Attorney at the Legal Aid Society's Juvenile Rights Division for nearly 10 years, where she represented hundreds of children and teenagers… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


I Would Never …

Conflict Management Blog by Cinnie NobleThe other day a coaching client told me that she became angry at a man she works with who criticized how she managed a situation....

By Cinnie Noble

You Can Avoid Disputes in Business Relationships

A small business is a relationship business.   Relationships with suppliers, customers, business partners and employees can thrive when the business is working well but when relationships don't work, the...

By Joanna Wares

Logic Overpowers Intuition: The Obama WAR!!!

President Obama decided to send 30,000 troops to Afghanistan in the next six months and then begin pulling them out a year after. He overlooked negotiation and mediation as effective...

By Luis Miguel Diaz

Find a Mediator