Creativity v Defensiveness

It is the function of creative men to perceive the relations between thoughts, or things, or forms of expression that may seem utterly different, and to be able to combine them into some new forms – the power to connect the seemingly unconnected.

— William Plomer

“She sure is creative.”

“He sure is defensive.”

Which would you prefer to be the subject of?

All of us pride ourselves in being creative, whether artistically or professionally. To be defensive, on the other hand, implies weakness or, if you will, a lack of aggressiveness.

As practicing attorneys, we prosecute or defend claims, and, in that limited context, to be defensive may carry a very different connotation. However, in the context of a settlement negotiation, or in a mediation, defensiveness suggests an arbitrary or obstinate frame of mind, an attitude connoting a lack of cooperation and an unwillingness to negotiate with an open mind – a sure-fire road to failure.

Mediators are trained to spot areas for creativity, while remaining neutral and unbiased. Legal advocates often have trouble with this concept, because they believe their objective is to win at any cost. In truth, creativity is a talent available to all legal practitioners and should be utilized a lot more than it ordinarily is.

I have honestly been stuck at times to devise a means of breaking a logjam in a mediated negotiation, when, suddenly, the attorney on one side or the other sugctional device available to the mediator as well as both sides of a legal dispute, and it should not be ignored.

Just as an artist creates an original painting or sculpture that communicates a unique message to its viewers, attorneys by their very professional training have the talent to be creative, especially in the course of a settlement negotiation. Use that creativity. Use it to the advantage of your client. Use it to avoid the costly, time-consuming, stressful and uncertain outcome of a trial. “Exercise the power to connect the seemingly unconnected.”


Edward P. Ahrens

Ed Ahrens has been a member of the Florida Bar for over 43 years. He is a certified state and federal court mediator in Tampa, Florida. He is also a freelance writer and former president of National Writers Association, South Florida Chapter. He is the author of the popular book,… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


How Do You Get Them To. . .?

Institute for the Study of Conflict Transformation by Dan SimonWhen I spend a day teaching mediators who were originally trained in a Facilitative approach, many questions start with “So how...

By Dan Simon

Reluctant to Mediate

Mediation is a wonderful way for people to resolve disputes. But before mediation can begin, all parties to the dispute must be willing to participate. Sometimes one of the parties...

By Norman Pickell

I Didn’t Mean it That Way

Cinergy Coaching by Cinnie NobleIt seems statements that go like, “I didn’t mean it that way” are ones we use when something we said or how we said it is...

By Cinnie Noble

Find a Mediator