Court of Appeal Overturns Class Action Settlement Arrived at in Mediation

From the First Mediation Blog of Jeff Krivis and Mariam Zadeh.

The California Court of Appeal in Kullar v. Foot Locker Retail, Inc. found that the trial court abused its discretion in finding the terms of the class action settlement to be fair, reasonable, and adequate where the record failed to establish what investigation counsel conducted or what information counsel reviewed on which counsel based their assessment of the strength of the class members’ claims.

The Court further found that the record lacked sufficient information for the trial court to intelligently evaluate the amount in controversy and the realistic range of outcomes of the litigation. Furthermore, the fact that the settlement was reached during mediation did not eliminate the trial court’s obligation to evaluate the terms of the settlement. If there were some relevant information that was subject to a privilege that the trial court needed to respect, other data should have been provided that would have enabled the court to make an independent assessment of the adequacy of the settlement terms.

The Court of Appeals held that just because communications made during mediation and writings prepared for use in mediation were inadmissible and not subject to compulsory production did not mean that underlying data, not otherwise privileged, was also immune from production.

                        author

Jeffrey Krivis

Improvisational Negotiation. This phrase summarizes Krivis’ philosophy for a successful and dynamic mediated negotiation. A successful mediation needs both keen legal insight gained from years of litigation experience and cannot be scripted. Exploring this idea with further study led Krivis to venture on the stage as a stand-up comedian. Ultimately,… MORE >

                        author

Mariam Zadeh

Mariam Zadeh was an active trial lawyer in New York City until September 11, 2001, at which time her life was dramatically changed. She moved to Los Angeles, obtained her L.L.M. in Alternative Dispute Resolution from the Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution at Pepperdine University, and became a partner with… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

ODR in India: Opportunity, Challenges, and the Obvious

This article will provide a brief overview of the current status of Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) in India by examining the opportunity and challenges the ODR brings and faces receptively...

By Nisshant Laroia, Sandeep Bhalothia
Category

Resolving frozen Misperceptions between two Warring Parties

I’m publishing this newsletter series to discuss the nuances of the four timeless topics for people and organizations: conflict, change, transformation, and consciousness. Please subscribe to never miss an article. I would...

By Ralph Kilmann
Category

Larry Fong: Mediation Not a Profession – Video

Larry Fong shares his view of mediation not being a profession, but instead mediators are professionals that are given the capacity to practice by institutional bodies.

By Larry Fong

Find a Mediator

X
X
X