Confidentiality Update: Petition for Review filed with the California Supreme Court in the Estate of Thottam

From the First Mediation Blog of Jeff Krivis and Mariam Zadeh.

California Supreme Court

California Supreme Court

On September 23, 2008, Stephen L. Kaplan, Esq., counsel for Respondent Jameson Thottam, filed a Petition for Review with the California Supreme Court in the matter of Estate of Thottam. Therein Mr. Kaplan presented the Court with two issues to consider:

ISSUE #1: Fair v. Bakhtiari, (2006) 40 Cal. 4th 189, 192 held that subdivision (b) of Evidence Code §1123 does not waive mediation confidentiality for purported settlement agreements created during mediation that are “simply a memorandum of terms for inclusion in a future agreement.” Does the same apply to subdivision (c) of Evidence Code §1123 so that purported written settlement agreements created during mediation are inadmissible at trial if it is unclear from the face of the document whether the document is a settlement agreement or “simply a memorandum of terms for inclusion in a future agreement”?

ISSUE #2: When the parties disagree whether a writing created during mediation is a settlement agreement, is mediation confidentiality waived under Evidence Code §1123(c) by signing a mediation agreement before the mediation commences that acknowledges that mediation is confidential “except as may be necessary to enforce any agreements resulting from the Meeting” and “shall be considered privileged and, as a settlement conference, non-admissible under the
California Evidence Code in any current or future litigation between us”? [1CT(Civ) 104].

We adressed the history of the Thottam case and the Court of Appeal’s decision underlying the Petition for review on September 15, 2008. For more information, please see:  Recent Confidentiality Decisions … In a Nutshell.

We will be keeping a close eye on the filings in this case and will report back as the story develops.

                        author

Jeffrey Krivis

Improvisational Negotiation. This phrase summarizes Krivis’ philosophy for a successful and dynamic mediated negotiation. A successful mediation needs both keen legal insight gained from years of litigation experience and cannot be scripted. Exploring this idea with further study led Krivis to venture on the stage as a stand-up comedian. Ultimately,… MORE >

                        author

Mariam Zadeh

Mariam Zadeh was an active trial lawyer in New York City until September 11, 2001, at which time her life was dramatically changed. She moved to Los Angeles, obtained her L.L.M. in Alternative Dispute Resolution from the Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution at Pepperdine University, and became a partner with… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Mediation Failures to be Blamed on Chairs

Next time your fantastic mediation skills failed to guide your parties to settlement (hey that’s the only sign of success right?), it might be the chair’s fault.  Yes, I said...

By Jeff Thompson
Category

What UK Mediators Charge

In a kiss and tell article in the latest issue of The Mediator Magazine all is revealed about UK mediators' charge out rates in The Price is Wrong "... Setting...

By Geoff Sharp
Category

When You’re Ready to Seriously Negotiate that 10-Year Case, Read 50 Blog Posts that Will Make You a Better Negotiator

Over at B-School today, you'll find a collection of blog posts that will give you an entire semester's worth of negotiation knowledge, training and (if you practice) experience. Don't miss...

By Victoria Pynchon

Find a Mediator

X
X
X