As Marriage Equality Disputes Arise, so Does Opportunity for ADR

JAMS ADR Blog by Chris Poole

Recently the United States Supreme Court issued long anticipated rulings in the first marriage cases to reach the high court – United States v. Windsor and Hollingsworth v. Perry. Taken together, the decisions represent a significant step in the central civil rights issue of this era – the rights and responsibilities of same-sex couples to marry. The cases do not hold that there is a federal constitutional right guaranteeing same-sex couples the right to marry. The Justices of the Supreme Court sidestepped that issue on procedural grounds and the Justices’ dueling opinions foretell the arguments that will continue in states that do not recognize such unions.

It is important to understand that there will be a myriad of implementation issues, particularly for validly married same-sex couples who reside in a state that does not recognize such marriages. It is estimated that there are more than 1,000 federal statutes and related regulations that consider the parties’ marital status. Some benefits turn on the place where the marriage occurs (immigration), while others focus on the law of the state of the parties’ residence (Social Security). Without question, state and federal courts will be at the center of the debate as a consequence of challenges in pending cases, to newly adopted regulations and interpretation of state law to a myriad of factual settings.

As a consequence, there remain numerous issues for couples to navigate in the family law arena when considering whether to marry, while married and in the course of dissolution. If parties reside and were married in a state that recognizes same-sex marriages, legal issues will be governed by the well-developed body of law applicable to married couples. For parties who do not reside in such a state, the analysis will more complicated because many state law decisions turn on where the parties live. Thus, state laws that oppose same-sex marriages may result in findings contrary to the parties’ intentions. A further layer of analysis may turn on whether the parties are domestic partners or in civil unions and how the state addresses the rights of parties in such unions.

When considering the many unresolved questions, the parties should seek skilled professionals to identify the issues and fashion a plan to address the uncertainties of this evolving area of the law. This is particularly the case when children are involved. A mediator can understand the personal and family dynamics and how the parties’ values and beliefs impact the resolution of their issues. Additionally, a neutral can be effectively utilized to enable the parties to control the outcome of any pending dispute rather than the parties take the risk of an adverse result in this rapidly changing area of the law.

Given the many questions that remain, same-sex couples need guidance from knowledgeable practitioners and where the parties disagree, the assistance of effective and knowledgeable neutrals. The marriage cases set the stage for an in depth examination of the rights and responsibilities of married same sex couples; the cases did not resolve the issues.

                        author

Patrick Mahoney

  Hon. Patrick J. Mahoney (Ret.) brings to his full-time ADR practice over 43 years of legal experience as a civil litigator and judge. Judge Mahoney’s unique career has covered a wide-range of matters including business/commercial, securities, antitrust, trade secrets, environmental, employment, family law, civil rights, insurance, real property, attorneys fees,… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Resolving Property Disputes In The Millennium

INTRODUCTION The attractive feature of this particular lecture is that it allows us to say almost anything about the state of dispute resolution in this Millennium year and, more importantly,...

By Anthony Salata, Nicholas Cheffings
Category

The History of Mediation and Why It Is Still in Use Today

Mediation is a process of conflict resolution that involves a neutral party and two conflicting parties. This neutral party is a mediator whose function is to settle the differences between...

By Jakob Vinther, Thomas Todd Reynolds
Category

Thoughts on Mediation, Barack Obama, and Our Political Future

The emergence of Barack Obama as the front-runner for the Democratic nomination, and thus for the Presidency of the United States, presents us with unprecedented opportunities to influence global dispute...

By Kenneth Cloke

Find a Mediator

X
X
X