An Idle Threat

From the Blog of Phyllis G. Pollack.


       At some point in just about every dispute that I have mediated, one of the parties has said to me, “This is our final offer – tell the other side to take it or leave it!”

      How do I respond? It depends upon the situation at the time. In an interesting article entitled “Threat Response at the Bargaining Table” in the January 2008 issue of the Harvard Negotiation Newsletter, the authors suggest the following response.

      First, immediately call for a break – take a time out to allow the parties to calm down rather than storm out of the mediation. Then once the party is calm, analyze the threat: is it one that the party is likely to follow through on or was it simply made in the heat of the moment and so should be ignored? Is the threat one that was made – not for the other party’s benefit – but in an effort to save face with third parties who may or may not be participating in the mediation? If so, do not take the threat seriously.

      However, if you believe the threat may be serious, then you need to defuse the situation. To do this, paraphrase back to the party what you heard her say, to make sure you heard it correctly. Often, as a result of the paraphrasing, the party will realize that she did not mean to say what you heard – it “came out” wrong or you “heard” it wrong. This provides her with an opportunity to save face and claim it was a misunderstanding.

      Further, you can simply ask broad open-ended questions to the party in response to the threat, in an effort to understand why she made the ultimatum. By asking such questions, the party will reveal her reasoning or thought process, and in the process of doing so, may change her mind. Again, a “misunderstanding” or a “miscommunication” may be uncovered that allows the party to save face and propose something different and not so threatening.

      The above two suggestions are predicated on “active listening” – to really listen to what is being said and what is not being said: To understand and acknowledge the emotions behind the words. Oftentimes, simply acknowledging that the other person is angry or frustrated greatly defuses the situation and builds forward momentum. Once you acknowledge how the other party feels and what is the situation from her perspective or side of the table, she will be more inclined to work with you in resolving the problem.

       So. . . the next time you are in a negotiation or a mediation and the other party makes a threat. . . don’t react with a knee-jerk response. Rather, sit back, take a deep breathe and analyze why and where the threat is coming from. Should you simply ignore it or take it as a signal of something deeper that is going on and use “active listening” to find out? . . .Using such a measured response will more likely lead to a resolution instead of everyone storming out in a huff!

        . . . Just something to think about.   


Phyllis Pollack

Phyllis Pollack with PGP Mediation uses a facilitative, interest-based approach. Her preferred mediation style is facilitative in the belief that the best and most durable resolutions are those achieved by the parties themselves. The parties generally know the business issues and priorities, personalities and obstacles to a successful resolution as… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Mediation Marathon

PGP Mediation Blog by Phyllis G. PollackI have mixed emotions. Why? Recently, I have conducted multiple mediations simultaneously in matters involving the same plaintiff’s counsel and defendant’s counsel. These are...

By Phyllis Pollack

Jim Melamed Selected For First APFM Outstanding Mediator Award

After a nominations process open to all Academy of Professional Family Mediators (APFM) members, Jim Melamed, CEO, was selected to receive APFM's first "APFM Outstanding Professional Family Mediator Award."...

By Academy of Professional Family Mediators , James Melamed, J.D., Michael Aurit

4 Things You Definitely Need to Become an Accomplished Online Mediator

After the outbreak of the coronavirus, many mediators around the world had to learn how to offer online mediation to their clients - most of them using a video conferencing...

By Giuseppe Leone

Find a Mediator