A Shifting COnversation

Arnold W. Zeman’s blog

One of the key premises in transformative practice is that there are naturally-occurring shifts in conversation moving from confusion and uncertainty to clarity and strength of self, moving from self-absorption to openness and responsiveness to the other.  These shifts cycle back and forth between confusion and clarity, between self-absorption and recognition throughout conversations.  The central goal of the transformative intervenor is to support these shifts.  The objective is to create a space where the speaker can listen to herself and the listener can listen to the speaker somewhat differently.  But transformative moments occur without third party intervenors.  Let’s look at these excerpts from an essay by Sylvia Boorstein, “We Shall Overcome Fixed Views”, published in the Shambhala Sun:

I was one of ten people seated together at a benefit dinner to raise funds for the San Francisco Zen Hospice Project and the conversation, after preliminary introductions, turned to the election results.
. . .

A man sitting across from me, the one person who had been silent during the political conversation, then said, “I think I am the only person at this table who voted differently from everyone else.” There was a momentary pause, very brief, and then a woman said, “I think it is very courageous of you to have told us that.”

We would say that the man’s statement is a clear example of a shift from a state of relative weakness/isolation to strength of self (empowerment) in expressing his contrary political views.  In the same way, the woman’s comment was a shift from solidarity with the rest of the group, let’s call it self-absorption (group absorption might be better) to openness/responsiveness to the other (recognition).

“Well, I did vote differently,” the man continued. “I’ve been a banker all my life and I thought the Republican economic plan was the better plan.” He paused, and then said, “But I’m glad it turned out the way it did. I can see that this is an epochal moment for America and sends an important message to the world.”

Here, validated by the woman’s comments, the man explains himself some more in very clear terms, and offers recognition to the members of the group by acknowledging his satisfaction with the way the election turned out.

Then, the essayist, Sylvia Boorstein, takes away from this exchange what we might call the true transformative coda, that differences can be broached other than adversarially through force or a rights framework, on the basis of our common humanity:

I was, first of all, surprised. . .Presented with the data, this person, who seemed so intelligent and congenial and goodhearted in his opening remarks, who supports this same good cause that all of us at this dinner are supporting, who realizes that this is an epochal event in history, has another view of what will be the programs that make a better world. I can separate the person from his view. I can disagree with his view but I do not need to make him my enemy.

Read the entire essay here.


Arnold W. Zeman

After over 33 years in the public service of Canada, the last 20 of which as an executive, I retired from government in 2006 to pursue my passion to help people resolve their differences non-adversarially. I have been trained by the best in the field in both the public and… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Sometimes the Answer is “No”

Mediation and Business Consulting by Kathleen Kauth.Mediation is often considered the best option to work out a conflict and salvage a relationship.  When entering into a mediation, one hopes that...

By Kathleen Kauth

The Handshake: A Eulogy

History of the handshake, its societal and business uses, its importance in mediation and negotiation, and what lies ahead now that the handshake has become a casualty of Covid-19 The...

By Lucia Kanter St Amour

Valentines Day and Divorce

Valentine’s Day;  the most romantic day of the year.  Some love it, some hate it, but you cannot deny that Valentine’s Day is synonymous with love, affection, adoration, chocolates, and...

By Marian Grande

Find a Mediator